Why Your SEO Isn't Working & How to Turn it Around

You’ve done it all—keyword research, on-page content optimization, link building, submitting your sitemap to Google Search Console, and consistently publishing high-quality blogs.

‍

Yet, despite checking every SEO box, there’s no pay off. Your rankings remain stagnant, organic traffic is underwhelming, and conversions aren’t improving. It’s frustrating, but you’re not alone.

‍

Many business owners and marketers find themselves asking: “Why isn’t my SEO working?”

‍

The truth is, SEO is a long game and has overcome some drastic changes over the past 5 years. There are often hidden roadblocks preventing success. 

‍

In this guide, we’ll break down the most common reasons SEO strategies fall short—and, more importantly, how to fix them.

‍

What is SEO? 

Before diving into why your SEO efforts may not be working, let’s take a step back and define what SEO actually is.

‍

SEO (Search Engine Optimization), is the practice of optimizing your website and content to improve visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs). It involves a combination of strategies designed to attract organic (non-paid) traffic from search engines like Google, Bing, and Yahoo.

‍

Over the years, SEO has undergone significant transformations. Not long ago, ranking well was often about stuffing pages with keywords and accumulating as many backlinks as possible—without much concern for content quality.

‍

However, as search engines evolve, so has SEO. Today, search algorithms prioritize high-quality, relevant, and user-focused content while penalizing manipulative tactics. Success in SEO now depends on a strategic, ethical approach that aligns with both search engine guidelines and user intent.

‍

Now, with this refresh, we’re ready to dive into the common reasons your SEO isn’t working. 

‍

Common Reasons Why Your SEO Isn't Working

1. Your Keywords Are Outdated or Ineffective

When I first started in SEO, I believed success was all about targeting keywords with the highest search volume. But over time, I realized that search intent is what truly matters.

‍

High-volume keywords are often broad, highly competitive, and difficult to rank for. Modern SEO has shifted away from these generic terms in favor of long-tail, intent-driven keywords—phrases that align more closely with what users are actually searching for.

‍

The goal is to discover niche keywords that connect with your target audience and match their intent, whether they’re looking for information, making a purchase, or seeking a service.

‍

Tools to Refine Your Keyword & Content Strategy

Leverage these tools to identify high-impact keywords and optimize your content:

• SEMrush Keyword Research – Explore SEMrush’s extensive keyword database to find relevant, low-competition keywords.
• SEMrush Keyword Gap Analysis – Identify keyword opportunities by comparing your rankings to competitors.
• SEMrush Position Tracker – Monitor your keyword rankings and track performance over time.
• Google Search Suggestions – Use Google’s autocomplete and “People Also Ask” sections for real-time keyword insights.
• Google Search Console (GSC) – Discover up to 1,000 keywords your site already ranks for and identify new optimization opportunities.

‍

2. Poor Technical SEO Performance 

Even if your content is well-optimized and you have a strong backlink profile, technical issues can silently hurt your rankings. Search engines prioritize websites that load quickly, are mobile-friendly, and provide a seamless user experience.

Here are some key technical SEO problems to watch out for:

‍

Indexing & Crawlability

If search engines can’t properly crawl and index your site, your content won’t appear in search results, no matter how well-optimized it is.

Common Causes

• Noindex tags accidentally blocking important pages.
• A poorly structured robots.txt file, preventing Google from crawling key sections.
• Missing or outdated XML sitemaps that don’t reflect recent content changes.

‍

How to Fix

1. Check Your Indexing Status in Google Search Console (GSC)
   
   • Go to GSC → Pages to view indexed and non-indexed pages.
   • Ensure all necessary webpages are indexed.
   • If critical pages are missing, request indexing directly within GSC.

2. Submit or Update Your XML Sitemap
   
   • Navigate to GSC → Sitemaps to check if your sitemap is submitted and up to date.
   • If missing or outdated, generate a new sitemap (using Yoast SEO, Rank Math, or an XML sitemap generator) and submit it.

3. Review & Optimize Your robots.txt File
   
   • Go to GSC → Settings → robots.txt to check for issues.
   • Ensure important sections of your site aren’t blocked from crawling.
   • If necessary, modify your robots.txt file to allow Googlebot access to key pages.

‍

Slow Website Speed & Performance Issues

Google considers page speed a ranking factor, and a slow-loading site can increase bounce rates, leading to lower rankings. 

‍

Common Causes

Some common areas that impact your website’s page speed and performance can include

• Large, unoptimized images 
• Excessive JavaScript & CSS 
• Slow server response times or lacking caching
• Too many third-party scripts, like ads or tracking codes 

‍

How to Fix

Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights that analyze your site’s speed and suggest optimizations. If your site has a weak performance, try these fixes: 

• Compress Images to reduce file size
• Minimize CSS and JavaScript by removing unused code
• Use browser caching and enable lazy loading for images and videos.
• Leverage a Content Delivery Network (CDN) like Cloudflare to serve content faster.

‍

Mobile-Friendliness & Core Web Vitals

With mobile-first indexing, Google primarily evaluates your mobile site for rankings. If your website isn’t optimized for smaller screens, it can lead to poor user experience and ranking drops.

‍

Common Causes

• A non-responsive web design that doesn’t adapt to desktop or mobile layouts
• Text too small to read or links/buttons too close together.
• Slow mobile load times due to heavy elements or excessive redirects.

‍

How to Fix

Go to your Google Search Console, and check the Core Website Vitals report. This measures loading performance, responsiveness, and visual stability of all pages through the lens of Google. 

‍

In Google Search Console, navigate to the Core Web Vitals Report to analyze key performance metrics, including:

• Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) – Optimize large images and text to load faster.
• First Input Delay (FID) – Reduce excessive JavaScript that slows interactivity.
• Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) – Prevent content from unexpectedly shifting on the page.

‍

‍

For Mobile-Friendliness issues, also use Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test to check responsiveness. Ensure your mobile layout is as strong (if not stronger), than your desktop layout. This may include fixing the layout of your mobile site to ensure text is readable, buttons are easily clickable, and content scales correctly. 

‍

Broken Links & Redirect Errors

There's nothing more confusing than clicking a link only to find yourself on an unexpected page or encountering a '404 Error Page' instead.

‍

Broken links and improper redirects create a poor user experience and can weaken your site’s authority in Google’s eyes. Removing pages may be essential for content updates, but doing it incorrectly can result in numerous performance-related problems on your website.

‍

Common Causes

• 404 errors from deleted or moved pages without proper redirection.
• Redirect chains that slow down page load times.
• Internal links pointing to outdated URLs.

‍

How to Fix

• Utilize a Website Crawler Platform, like SEMRush, Screaming Frog, or Ahrefs to run a Site Audit on your website. This will be able to detect a variety of performance-related issues like broken links. 

• Implement 301 redirects for any outdated URLs to guide users and search engines to the correct pages.

• Regularly audit and update internal links to ensure they point to live pages

‍

3. On-Page SEO Issues

 On-page SEO is the foundation of your website’s search visibility. A well-performing website alone won't suffice; if your content isn't tailored to convey to Google the subject matter and target audience of your page, it will hurt your ranking potential.

‍

Below are the most common on-page SEO mistakes that could be holding your site back.

‍

Lack of High-Quality, Engaging Content

Content is the heart of SEO. Search engines prioritize valuable, relevant, and well-structured content that satisfies user intent. If your content is outdated, thin, or lacks engagement, Google is less likely to rank it.

‍

Common Issues

• Thin or duplicate content – Pages with little valuable information or copied content from other sources.
• Not matching search intent – Content that doesn’t fully answer users’ questions or provide what they’re looking for.
• Lack of structure & readability – No headings, long paragraphs, and poor formatting, making it hard to read.

‍

How to Fix It

• Create in-depth, well-structured content that fully answers search queries.
• Use formatting best practices (H1s, H2s, bullet points, short paragraphs).
• Incorporate multimedia (images, infographics, videos) to improve engagement.
• Regularly update old content to keep it fresh and relevant.

‍

Poor Keyword Optimization

Even the best content won’t rank if it’s not optimized with the right keywords. Poor keyword usage can mean targeting overly broad terms or stuffing content with keywords unnaturally.

‍

Common Issues

• Overuse of keywords (keyword stuffing), making content look spammy.
• Ignoring long-tail, intent-driven keywords that attract high-converting traffic.
• Not optimizing title tags, meta descriptions, and headers with relevant keywords.

‍

How to Fix It

• Focus on long-tail, intent-based keywords for better rankings.
• Naturally incorporate primary and secondary keywords in content.
• Optimize title tags, meta descriptions, headers, and image alt text for search engines.

‍

Weak Internal Linking Strategy

Internal linking helps distribute page authority, improves crawlability, and enhances user navigation. Without it, search engines and users struggle to find relevant content.

Common Issues

• Pages lacking internal links, making them "orphan pages."
• Using too many links with non-descriptive anchor text ("click here" instead of keyword-rich text).
• Uneven distribution of link equity, where some pages get too many links and others none.

‍

How to Fix It

• Add relevant internal links to guide users to useful content.
• Use descriptive anchor text that reflects the target page’s topic.
• Ensure important pages are easily accessible from your site's navigation.

‍

Missing or Poorly Optimized On-Page Elements

On-page elements like title tags, meta descriptions, header tags, and image alt text play a huge role in SEO rankings and user experience.

‍

Common Issues

• Missing or duplicate title tags & meta descriptions.
• Not using header tags (H1, H2, H3, etc.) to structure content properly.
• Images missing alt text, making them inaccessible to search engines and visually impaired users.

‍

How to Fix It

• Write unique, keyword-optimized title tags and meta descriptions for every page.
• Use header tags (H1 for the main title, H2s for subheadings, etc.) to improve readability.
• Add alt text to all images for better accessibility and ranking in Google Image Search.

‍

‍

4. Off-Page SEO Issues

Off-page SEO is just as critical as on-page optimization. It helps search engines determine your website's credibility, trustworthiness, and authority. Without a strong off-page SEO strategy, even the best content may struggle to rank.

‍

Below are common off-page SEO mistakes that could be holding your site back.

‍

Weak Backlink Profile

Backlinks act as votes of confidence from other websites, signaling to Google that your content is valuable. However, not all backlinks are created equal—quality matters more than quantity.

Over the past years, the approach to link-building strategies has drastically changed. Link-building used to be about acquiring as many backlinks as possible, through manipulative methods like link farms and spammy guest posts. A common example is getting listed on low-quality, fake directories that exist solely to host backlinks, rather than providing real value to users. 

‍

Today, search engines have become much smarter, penalizing these outdated practices and prioritizing high-quality, relevant backlinks from authoritative sources.

‍

How to Improve Backlink Profile

• Run a Backlink Analysis with tools like SEMRush, Ahrefs, or Moz to analyze your backlink profile. 
• Remove or disavow toxic backlinks that may harm your rankings.
• Focus on earning links from high-authority, relevant websites in your industry. 
• Use guest blogging, digital Press Releases, and HARO (Help a Reporter Out) to acquire quality links.

‍

Ignoring Local SEO (For Businesses with a Physical Presence)

For businesses with physical locations or service areas, Local SEO plays a crucial role in visibility. Neglecting it means missing out on highly targeted, location-based traffic.

Ways to improve your local presence include: 

• Ensuring you have a verified Google Business Profile (GBP)
• Using accurate and consistent NAP (Name, Address, Phone) information across all directories 
• Increasing presence on local listings and directories that are relevant to your industry
• Requesting and Responding to customer reviews on GBP, Yelp, and other essential directories. 

‍

5. Analytics 

SEO isn’t a one-time effort—it’s an ongoing process that requires constant monitoring and adaptation. Search engines update their algorithms regularly, competitors adjust their strategies, and user behavior evolves. 

‍

If you're not tracking your SEO performance and making data-driven adjustments, you risk falling behind.

‍

Some key platforms and SEO metrics to monitor include: 

• Google Search Console (GSC) to measure metrics like Impressions, Clicks, CTR, Average Position & Queries. 
• Google Analytics (GA) to track organic traffic, user behavior, how long users are on your website, and conversions. 
• SEMRush Keyword Research & Position Tracking to find keyword improvements, changes in rankings, and competitive analyses. 
• SEMRush Backlink Analysis to analyze Authority Score, find toxic backlinks, and identify prospects for link-building. 

Conclusion

SEO is a constantly evolving process, and there’s no single “set it and forget it” strategy. If your current efforts aren’t delivering the results you want, chances are hidden roadblocks are holding your website back.

‍

While optimizing your SEO strategy takes time, effort, and continuous adaptation, you don’t have to do it alone. If you’ve been working tirelessly but still aren’t seeing the rankings, traffic, or conversions you expected, it may be time to partner with an experienced SEO agency.

‍

At WD Strategies, we help businesses like yours uncover SEO challenges, implement data-driven strategies, and drive measurable growth. Whether you need a technical SEO overhaul, content optimization, or a long-term organic strategy, our team is here to help.

‍

Ready to take your SEO to the next level? Contact us today to see how we can help you achieve your digital marketing goals.

‍